Pitocin and Medical Negligence: What Every Expectant Parent Should Know

As a Texas medical malpractice attorney who’s handled numerous birth injury cases, I’ve seen firsthand the devastating consequences that can result from the misuse of Pitocin during labor and delivery. While this synthetic hormone can be a valuable medication and tool for managing labor, its improper use can lead to serious complications for both mother and baby. In this article, we’ll dive into what Pitocin is, its uses, risks, and the legal implications when things go wrong. Read more about the hidden dangers of excessive uterine activity in labor.

Understanding Pitocin

Pitocin is the brand name for synthetic oxytocin, a hormone naturally produced by the body that causes uterine contractions. It’s commonly used in hospitals to:

1. Induce labor when it hasn’t started naturally
2. Augment labor that has slowed or stalled
3. Control postpartum bleeding

While Pitocin can be incredibly useful in these situations, it’s not without risks. The U.S. Food & Drug Administration (FDA) classifies Pitocin as a “high-alert medication,” which means it has a heightened risk of causing significant patient harm when used incorrectly.

The Risks of Pitocin

A mother named Angela was admitted to a Dallas hospital’s labor and delivery ward for induction of labor at 41 weeks into her pregnancy (gestation). Her obstetrician (OB/GYN) ordered Pitocin to start contractions, to be managed and titrated by the labor and delivery nurses. Within hours, Angela’s contractions became intense and frequent, but the nursing staff didn’t recognize the signs of excessive uterine activity.

Angela’s baby started showing signs of distress on the fetal heart monitor, with repeated late decelerations—a red flag that the baby isn’t tolerating labor well. Despite these warning signs, the nurses didn’t notify the doctor or stop – or even reduce – the Pitocin rate. Angela’s excessive contractions continued for hours. By the time the doctor learned what was going on a called for an emergency C-section, Angela’s baby had suffered severe oxygen deprivation, resulting in cerebral palsy and hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (HIE). Read more in our article how Pitocin causes excessive contractions, brain injury in baby.

This case illustrates some of the primary risks associated with Pitocin:

1. Uterine Hyperstimulation: Pitocin can cause contractions that are too strong, too long, or too close together. This can reduce blood flow to the baby, leading to oxygen deprivation.

2. Fetal Distress: The intense contractions caused by Pitocin can put stress on the baby, leading to changes in heart rate and potentially causing fetal distress.

3. Uterine Rupture: In rare cases, especially in women with previous C-sections, Pitocin can cause the uterus to tear, a life-threatening emergency for both mother and baby.

4. Postpartum Hemorrhage: While Pitocin is used to prevent postpartum bleeding, overuse during labor can sometimes increase the risk of hemorrhage after delivery.

Legal Issues Surrounding Pitocin Use

From a legal standpoint, cases involving Pitocin often revolve around several key issues:

1. Improper Administration

The standard of care requires that Pitocin be administered carefully, starting with a low dose and gradually increasing as needed to achieve a favorable and safe contraction pattern. In Angela’s case, the continued use of Pitocin despite signs of fetal distress was a clear deviation from this standard. When the fetal monitoring strip doesn’t look reassuring, nurses should notify the obstetrician and reduce or stop Pitocin to allow the fetus time to recover before the stress of more contractions.

2. Inadequate Monitoring

Patients receiving Pitocin require continuous fetal monitoring. This includes tracking:

• The frequency, duration, and intensity of contractions
• The fetal heart rate
• The mother’s vital signs

Failure to properly monitor and interpret these signs can lead to missed opportunities to intervene when problems arise.

3. Delayed Response to Complications

When problems arise during Pitocin-augmented labor, swift action is crucial. This may include:

• Reducing or stopping the Pitocin infusion
• Changing the mother’s position
• Administering oxygen to the mother
• Notifying the doctor promptly
• Preparing for an emergency C-section

Delays in responding to signs of fetal distress or other complications can have serious consequences and may constitute medical negligence.

5. Inappropriate Use

The manufacturer’s label states that Pitocin is contraindicated (should never be used) in certain situations, including, “Where the uterus is already hyperactive or hypertonic.” This means that doctors and nurses need to carefully monitor uterine activity and adjust Pitocin dosing accordingly. To do otherwise can be considered negligence.

Proving Medical Negligence in Pitocin-Related Cases

To successfully pursue a medical malpractice claim involving Pitocin, plaintiffs must establish four key elements through expert testimony and evidence:

1. Duty of Care: We must show that the obstetrician and labor and delivery nurses owed professional duties to the patient. For hospital cases, this is easy to demonstrate.

2. Breach of Standard of Care: We need to demonstrate that the care provided fell below the accepted medical standard. This often involves expert testimony from obstetricians and labor and delivery nurses who can explain how the use and management of Pitocin deviated from accepted practices.

3. Causation: We must prove that the breach of the standard of care directly caused the injury to the mother or baby. Quite often, we rely on medical specialists, including neuroradiologists, pediatric neurologists, and neonatologists to provide this testimony.

4. Damages: Finally, we need to show that the injury resulted in significant damages. In cases of birth injuries like HIE or cerebral palsy, we retain experts to prepare life care plans. These studies frequently show that the cost of necessary future care will be many millions of dollars.

It’s important to note that the general statute of limitations for medical negligence claims in Texas is two years from the date of the injury, but there can be exceptions, particularly in cases involving minors. Even when the injured plaintiff is a baby, though, a significant chunk of damages belongs to the parents, and is likely time-barred if a claim isn’t pursued within two years.

Challenges in Pitocin-Related Cases

Pitocin-related cases are challenging and best handled by an experienced medical malpractice attorney for several reasons:

1. Complex Medical Evidence: These cases often involve interpreting fetal heart rate tracings, understanding the nuances of labor progression, and analyzing the effects of Pitocin on both mother and baby. This requires a deep understanding of obstetrical practice and the ability to work closely with medical experts.

2. Multiple Defendants: In many cases, multiple healthcare providers may share responsibility for Pitocin-related injuries. This can include the obstetrician, labor and delivery nurses, and the hospital itself. Determining the extent of each party’s liability requires careful analysis.

3. Causation Issues: Proving that the misuse of Pitocin directly caused the injury can be challenging, especially when there were pre-existing risk factors or other potential causes of the injury.

4. Defense Arguments: Defendants often argue that complications were due to the inherent risks of childbirth, genetics, or other factors unrelated to negligence, or that the injuries would have occurred regardless of Pitocin use.

Preventing Pitocin-Related Injuries

Doctors, nurses, and healthcare providers can reduce the risk of Pitocin-related injuries by:

1. Carefully assessing the need for Pitocin and considering alternative methods when appropriate

2. Starting with low doses of Pitocin and increasing gradually

3. Continuously monitoring both mother and baby during Pitocin administration

4. Promptly recognizing and responding to signs of fetal distress or excessive uterine activity

5. Being prepared to stop Pitocin administration and intervene quickly if complications arise

What to Do If You Suspect Pitocin-Related Negligence

If you believe that you or your baby has been harmed due to the misuse of Pitocin, it’s crucial to take action promptly. Here are some steps you can take:

1. Obtain Medical Records: Request complete copies of all relevant medical records, including labor and delivery notes, medication administration records, and fetal monitoring strips.

2. Seek Appropriate Medical Care: Ensure that you and your baby receive all necessary medical care and follow-up.

3. Document Everything: Keep a detailed record of symptoms, treatments, and any communications with healthcare providers.

4. Consult with a Specialized Attorney: Medical malpractice cases, especially those involving birth injuries, are complex. Experienced medical malpractice attorneys know how to handle these challenging cases.

As a top-rated, experienced Texas medical malpractice attorney, I’ve helped many families navigate the challenging aftermath of Pitocin-related birth injuries. These cases require a deep understanding of both medical and legal issues, as well as the ability to work with expert witnesses to build a strong case. Read more about how oxytocin/Pitocin medication errors linked to fetal distress, brain injury, and uterine rupture.

Remember, while Pitocin can be a valuable tool when used appropriately, its misuse can have devastating consequences. If you believe that you or your baby has been harmed due to the negligent use of Pitocin during labor and delivery in Texas, don’t hesitate to reach out for a free consultation.

Together, we can review your case, explain your legal options, and help you make informed decisions about how to proceed.

The journey to holding healthcare providers accountable for Pitocin-related injuries can be long and challenging, but it’s an important step in both securing the resources your family needs and preventing similar tragedies from happening to others in the future.